S. P. Gardebiter said:
That "cry" thing was a joke. But anyway, a member telling an admin that he has "no right" to do something... That's a joke too isn't it?
I was not joking. Your joke was a joke in bad taste. An insult is not made acceptable by calling it a joke. Plus, just because an admin has greater privileges than an average member doesn't mean they have a right to do anything they please.
S. P. Gardebiter said:
This is a community. A forum is always a social network. However if you're new, the other members and the admin have to accept you before you can call yourself one of "them".
Not really. As long as the new person is not a troll or other unpleasant character, they are automatically part of "them" just by being here.
S. P. Gardebiter said:
You have absolute no right to call yourself a senior member, even if you have a equal postnumber and activity, that's totally disrespectful to any senior member in the forums.
Oh really? Seniority is not based exclusively on time, you know. While you can't be a "senior" if you've only been here, say, a month, if you're active it makes sense to gain seniority earlier than someone who only posts occasionally.
S. P. Gardebiter said:
And showing off with your postnumber and activity and saying: "OMG I HAVE MOAR POSTS THAN SENIOR MEMBERS LOLZ, MY E-PENIS IS THE BIGGEST" is not something I will countenance. The senior members decide if you're being helpful or not and if you are one of them or not, because they ARE the community and therefor the biggest part of the forum.
(emphasis mine) No. The community is not just the senior members. The community is
all the members who post here, trolls excluded.
S. P. Gardebiter said:
A forum is a service that the admins provide you, but because they provide it to you, that doesn't mean they have to.
I can't deny that, except that it's not the admins providing the service. It's whoever hosts the place (which, if I'm not mistaken, is SkyeWelse).
S. P. Gardebiter said:
If you really read all my posts I've made in the last year then you know about 1/5 of my posts.
That's not very much. And that's what I mean, if you are new you have no experience with the other members. If you would be a senior, you would know that I was the one who did enforced the new anti spamming rules. DoubleThink, Andwhyisit and I made them. You don't know how the social climber is like if you're new. And you don't know how it was like 2 years ago or so.
So I haven't read all your posts. Big deal. I'm making a judgement from the large proportion of posts of yours that I
have seen. And really, the most recent posts are the most relevant, because people change over time.
S. P. Gardebiter said:
And that's why I call for example Wistil, andwhyisit or Lace rather a senior member than Void. Void maybe made some helpful posts, but I don't see any social experience, FAQ's, some new stuff, a good demo of a mod or something, instead he is going to complain about senior members having "no respect", because they posted some softcore pseudo-pornograhic images.
It's not necessary to write up a FAQ or create a mod in order to be a senior member. Simply being very helpful is good too, and Void, from what I've seen, tends to be very helpful.
S. P. Gardebiter said:
Just for calling someone a hypocrite you're a hypocrite. Because not everyone is jesus perfect.
You have no idea what you're talking about. My post was full of information; Shokobecher's was not. Some of the information in my post was even relevant.
And I know that no-one is perfect. I called him a hypocrite because he was one: that is, he made a post saying basically "don't spam!", yet with that post, he was spamming. It's not hypocrisy to call someone a hypocrite.
S. P. Gardebiter said:
That newbie would have no knowledge about the members (social experience) and would have contributed nothing to the forums.
Plus a random newbie with 25 years of hacking experience doesn't know how to hack Cave Story, before he is taking a look at it and learns about it.
To the first part: who cares. The fact is that such a hypothetical newbie is able to contribute a great deal to the forum and in deed probably will. Social experience is not a requirement, Knowledge about the members is optional. As for the second part, if he has 25 years of hacking experience, it will be pretty simple for him to hack Cave Story.
S. P. Gardebiter said:
You have no idea how wrong you are...
As a final note, I find it telling that several people agree with me, some or all of whom are in the group you classify as "senior members".