"The Skyloft knights were evidently a rescue corps dedicated to catching people that fell off Skyloft. They didn't clear the sky of monsters, remove the deadly animals from Skyloft, or even search for the missing child. Except for the schoolmaster, they had forgotten all about their martial history. Most weren't even aware there used to be a land on which their ancestors fought wars. The fencing salon appeared to be more for PE than developing a practical skillset. Other than Link, only one knight-student made it to the surface, and he was more of an engineer than a fighter. That is suggestive of the kind of education they received at the knight academy--they were there to maintain Skyloft and its population, not to fight. Link may be unusual in his affinity for the sword; probably because he feels inadequate compared to Groose and wants to impress Zelda with a frankly rather phallic symbol.
The Link of Twilight Princess is more of a scrapper. His people are under constant threat of Bokoblin depredations, and he doesn't hesitate to pick up his sword and go rescue a hostage. He has almost certainly been in combat before, practices for combat (owns a sword, and note the dummy in his front yard), and considers combat a normal part of his obligations. He is not merely a goat farmer (ranch hand, technically). He's obviously a member of the local militia and, in all probability, a combat veteran."
I found someone saying this on a different website and completely agree with this logic.
And due to this information and biase on my part (I won't lie), Tp Link wins. He's not just a Ranch Hand.
Tp Link also has the ability to transform into a wolf. And wolves are my absolute favorite animals. IN. THE. WORLD.
And if we were gonna add companions into the mix (which we probably aren't), Midna wins by a long shot against Fi, in my opinion.
I don't know, you guys might have different opinions.