In this Topic we rate eachother's Avatars/Sigs.

Kaeso

Avatar - 9/10
Sig - 5/10

I like the "realness" of the avatar over the "fakeness" of the sig.


andwhyisit

Avatar - 9/10 you did a good job even if it was just coloring.
Sig - 3/10 I dislike the "leet" part of it.

 

8 for the avatar
7 for the sig

 

Andwhyisit
Avatar- 8/10. Really nice job with the coloring. If only I was more of a Pokemon fanatic, I'd probably enjoy it more...
Sig- 9/10. Balcake Link is made of HUZZAH!

MetaSeraphim
Avatar- 8/10. Not sure where she (Elly?) originates from, but, hey, I won't complain!
Sig 8/10. It's original & something I can possibly relate to, since some of my dreams that "reveal the future" do come around in time, even if it takes a month or two. I may be misinterpetting it, though if I am, I won't change the score.


Anyway, my sig was changed 2 days ago, & my avatar pic was changed just recently. Not to force anyone to speak up, but... Any raters willing to share their opinion?

 

Kaeso
Avatar: 10/10 (I love this picture)
Signature: 7 (don't really like the picture, but it's arranged very well)
I fucking <3 Curly.

MetaSeraphim
Avatar: 7
Signature: 4.9
Kinda boring.

Andwhyisit
Avatar: 7 (good job)
Signature: 7 (lots of material everywhere)

Bad Beholder
Avatar: 8 (<3 Metal Slug; though Cindy is the only reason to get the new one, she's a REALLY good reason)
Signature: 7 (some of everything, it seems)

 

Kaeso
A: 4/10
S: 8/10 (I tend to prefer the idealized graphics to the realistic ones)

Meta
A: 4/10
S: 7/10 (meh, interesting, a bit odd, but overall appealing)

Andwhy
A: 6/10
S: 7/10 (I liked the leet and the cave story graphic, but I was too lazy to care about what the stuff beneath it meant)

BB
A: 5/10
S: 8/10

Kage
A: 7/10
S: 9/10 (rofl)

Joker
A: 7/10 (not very original, but effective and fitting, kind of like mine)
S: 7/10

@Meta, andwhy, BB: I liked your old avatars better (especially Meta's fancy crosshairs or whatever that was supposed to be, it looked really cool)


Edit: anyone care to rate my old sig (the wedge of cheese class written in Java)? I'll probably bring it back eventually; it's like my signature signature, if that makes any sense...

 

This one you mean? ^

I would have to say that both sigs are good, I can't seem to find one better than the other.

 

Yeah, that's the one I was talking about.

 

Naru I want your pink hair.

 

Naru I want your pink hair.

 

LMAO!

/caps

 

Superior.
.

 

At least that.



Andwhy
8/10 eh it cools
5/10 looks like some pregnant creature
8/10 I hate you

 

At least that.



Andwhy
8/10 eh it cools
5/10 looks like some pregnant creature
8/10 I hate you

You need to tell me what you are actually rating.

Though the sig is of an earthmover, which is something megawolf77 came up with. He did the lineart, I coloured. And it isn't pregnant (if that was what you were referring to), it has its legs crossed.

Original:
http://megawolf77.deviantart.com/art/Earth-movers-89495159

Coloured Version:
http://andwhyisit.deviantart.com/art/Earth-movers-coloured-99092151

 

avatar..7/10
sig....8/10

Not that I know your avatar is.

The Joker

 

Ooh, Joker, new sig, I likes!

I'll bump your rating up to 8/10.
I won't rate your avatar since I already did in my last post.

 

new sig! I thought this one would be better, because it is smaller.

 

Joker:
Sig: 8/10

 

Joker:
Sig: 8/10

Thanks!

 

^

OHEYYY...

Hmm... let's see...

Avi: 8/10 (Teh show be awesome)
Sig: 9/10 (Bigger pic. How cool!)

 

hahaha
avi - 6/10, old one was better, but then again, you did make it.
sig - 2/10, ?